Current INSIGHT on Windows NT/2000 eLetter
|
Volume 8, Issue 1 January, 2004 |
This issue of INSIGHT ON
WINDOWS® NT/2000/XP contains:
|
FALLACIES OF DEFRAGMENTATION #4: "Only Defrag Every Few Months" |
|
By
John L. Joseph, Diskeeper Development Section
A
friend of mine sent me a link to an article he read on the Internet, which
actually said:
"In
general, don't defrag too frequently. You can wear out your hard drive if you
defrag too often. Unless you uninstall a bunch of programs or do a lot of video
and audio editing, only defrag every few months—sooner if your drive is more
than 20 percent fragmented."
There are actually multiple fallacies in this one. Let's dig in.
Fallacy A:
"Only defrag every few months—sooner if your drive is more than 20 percent
fragmented."—The first fallacy here is that anyone will actually remember to do
this.
No
one in their right mind puts an entry in their Calendar to defragment on the
31st of March, the 30th of June, the 30th of September, and the 31st of
December.
Advising this indicates the writer thinks the only good defragmenter is a manual
defragmenter, which of course, means he thinks the only good defragmenter is the
built-in defragmenter, which doesn't have a scheduler. If you've used the
built-in defragmenter, you know that it's got serious limitations. On 95/98/Me,
the built-in defragmenter restarts whenever some other process accesses the
disk. So, in effect, it never finishes. In Windows XP, the built-in defragmenter
won't operate when the free space gets low, and has trouble defragmenting files
that need a large amount of contiguous space.
What
most people don't realize is how fast fragmentation accumulates on their
computer. This graph is the result of a little experiment I did during a period
where I was just using Internet Explorer and Word. It's not a file server; it's
just my little old desktop machine.

Note
that each test starts with zero excess file fragments. That means that each line
represents the fragments in only the RECENTLY created or modified files; in
other words, they're the files I was using THAT DAY. The old files were
defragmented. It's the new files
that get fragmented. So the fragmentation accumulates in and affects the files I
can least afford to have perform poorly.
Fallacy B:
"Only defrag every few months—sooner if your drive is more than 20 percent
fragmented."—It is a fallacy to believe that you can wait a few months before
checking to see if you have greater than twenty percent fragmentation.
If
you wait a few months, your disk volumes may be more than 20 percent fragmented,
so you really have to run the disk analysis every few days or a week to ensure
you're not more than twenty percent fragmented. So your Calendar for 2004
DOESN'T have four entries to defragment, it's got fifty or more, because you're
going to want to run the built-in defragmenter every week to see if you've
exceeded the twenty percent guideline.
Of
course, running a disk analysis every few days or weekly is a MANUAL task.
Again, this is unnecessary if one is using an automatic defragmenter.
The
real problem, however, is that the built-in defragmenter is SLOOOOOOOW and
resource-intensive.
So
what the writer is really saying is that he doesn't want to lose the use of his
machine very often and that he'll succumb to the use of the built-in
defragmenter every few months.
Also, using the “twenty percent” figure is horribly misleading. Remember,
fragmentation accumulates in the most recently used and modified files. So you
could be 100% fragmented and not realize it!
If
you use Diskeeper's Smart Scheduling™ you don't have to manually analyze every
week and you don't have to manually defragment every week.
Fallacy C:
"Only defrag every few months"—The fallacy here is that a few months is an
acceptable period of time to endure non-optimum performance on your machine.
Let
me share a little experiment. I turned off automatic defragmentation on my
desktop computer (2.4GHz) on Friday, and when I came in on Monday, I did my
usual start-of-week actions. One of the things I do is to run
Ad-Aware, a program that hunts down and removes spyware from my system. On
Monday, when I came in, I timed how long it took Ad-Aware to deep-scan my
system. It took 56 seconds. I didn't have it remove any items after this scan. I
then defragmented my boot volume, and re-ran the Ad-Aware deep-scan. This time
it took 35 seconds. That's a 40% reduction in elapsed time!
Do
you run a spyware hunter on your machine? Do you run an antivirus on your
machine? Take a look at this graph:

Yes,
it can take HOURS to run an antivirus scan on a volume with tens of thousands of
files!
If
you keep your machine defragmented, you'll SAVE TIME in running the necessary
maintenance functions on your machine. I'm not talking about saving time in
running your applications, that’s a given; I'm also talking about the time and
resources you'll save in these maintenance functions like spyware purging,
antivirus scanning and performing backups.
If
you wait a "few months" to defragment, the fragmentation accumulates to the
point where these simple maintenance tasks take longer and longer to run. This
is NOT what you want. I don't even have to survey you individually to know that.
Nobody paid good money for their machine and software to have it run at
below-optimum performance.
Fallacy D:
"You can wear out your hard drive if you defrag too often"—This is, on its face,
a fallacy.
I've
heard this for years. I have never seen an actual test done that proves it! It’s
simply something that injects FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt) into your life.
What
I KNOW is this—if I have a file that's in fifty fragments, and I access it twice
a week for three months, that's a total of 1,200 head movements. If I defragment
the same file, it's up to 100 head movements at the time it gets defragmented,
but it's only 1 head movement every time I look at it for the next three months.
100+24 = 124 head movements.
The
head can move 1,200 times for that file in three months or 124 times in the same
period of time. Which situation will lead to the drive failing sooner?
Yep.
The one that wasn't defragmented.
Of
course it’s easy to take the advice of some “authority” without actually
inspecting the situation. And it’s really easy to “just use the built-in
defragmenter”, except that no one remembers to do it. After all, it’s “free”.
Manual defragmenters usually get run about an hour after the computer’s user has
placed a call to Tech Support or the Help Desk because it’s part of the standard
way to get a computer running again. And if the system has been neglected it
takes HOURS to defragment it.
The
better solution is to use an automated background defragmenter that spruces up
your disk volumes, keeping them running at optimum performance without manual
intervention or evaluation as to how fragmented the system is.
Take Advantage of Special New
Year Volume License Pricing!
Click here for a quote.
To download Diskeeper Trialware today,
click here
For more information on Diskeeper
click here
|
Diskeeper / Undelete Home Edition Bundle Special |
|

|
View the New Diskeeper Quick Start Video! |
|
The
Diskeeper Quick Start Video is a short guide to installing, setting and
evaluating Diskeeper on your system in order to see the benefits of
defragmenting automatically with our award-winning product. It provides helpful
tips and recommended practices when evaluating and using Diskeeper.
To view this video now, click on
the link below.
http://www.execsoft.com/diskeeper/quickstart/restart.asp?ad2=eletter0104
Take Advantage of Special New Year’s Volume License
Pricing!
Click here for a quote.
To download Diskeeper Trialware today,
click here
For more information on Diskeeper
click here
Undelete saved my life. I was remotely accessing a client's server late at night
when I accidentally deleted their accounting software data. In a panic, I
immediately downloaded Undelete and installed on their NT server. The whole
directory structure was restored without losing a single file. What a relief. I
would recommend it in a heartbeat.
—TechnoClarity, Inc.
Time
is a luxury I don't have and using Sitekeeper speeds things up tremendously. I
use it a lot to push out all the security updates for Windows. I also like the
software inventory because it lets me keep track of what is on each and every
system at the office. I would definitely recommend it to others, especially if
you don't want to spend your whole life looking at the Windows update page.
—Magnum Pacific Inc.
The
"Set it and Forget"® it feature of Diskeeper—all of our administrators love this
feature Having a reliable scheduler take care of the fragmentation issues of
our servers means that I and the other administrators can focus our attention
elsewhere without having to worry about the disk status. For years we were
primarily a Novell shop and we were accustomed to the NetWare OS handling the
defragmentation of the drives. Since the transition to Windows, fragmented
volumes have been a major concern since server performance can suffer. Diskeeper
has taken that concern away since we know it's being taken care of without daily
interaction or the need for weekend hours just to take care of a
"defrag." Fortunately, all of our Win2K servers are recently installed and have
had Diskeeper on them nearly from day one. We have not had any stability issues
at all. The defragmenter is working great. Our systems support the file, print,
web services, and database activities of three USAF organizations. All of our
servers have minimal fragmentation now.
—US Central Command Eglin AFB and McDill AFB
Our
customers are improving conditions every day with Executive Software products.
To find out how these products can improve conditions in your company, network,
and even on your home computer, call your local reseller or contact an Executive
Software representative at 800-829-6468.
To Download Undelete Trialware
Now,
Click Here
To Download Sitekeeper Trialware
Now,
Click Here
Take Advantage of Our New Year
Special Pricing!
Click Here for an Online Quote
|
kickstartnews.com Gives Diskeeper 8.0 a Rave Review |
|
"This latest version of Diskeeper Professional is a keeper,” states
kickstartnews.com’s review of Diskeeper. “Our risky, real-world intensive
testing revealed its stability and resistance to errors. In regularly scheduled
use (the scheduling dialog is clear and simple to use), there's very little
you'll notice about Diskeeper's activities other than a smooth running, stable
system.”
kickstartnews.com put Diskeeper through a large battery of rigorous tests (which
they document in the article) and found it to be a winner! Read the full article
by clicking below.
http://www.kickstartnews.com/reviews/utilities/diskeeper_pro_8.html

If
you want to learn to program—or are simply interested in a refresher—buy and
read The Craft of Computer Programming by Craig Jensen. Craig is not only the
founder and CEO of Executive Software, he is also the author of Diskeeper disk
defragmenter, one of the best-selling utilities in the world.
Written in a friendly, straightforward style, The Craft of Computer Programming
is delivered in an easy-to-read electronic format with custom bookmarking, the
ability to annotate text, highlighting and more. A comprehensive, hyperlinked
index and glossary help you locate the exact information you need.
For a free preview, go to
www.craftof.com
http://www.jsiinc.com/reghack.htm
JSI, Inc. is a tried and true tips and tricks website
http://www.dougknox.com/
Doug’s pages contain tweaks and tips for Windows XP/95/98/Me
http://www.webtechgeek.com/Windows_2000_tips.htm
WebTechGeek.com has a special Windows 2000 News Reviews & Tip Page
FOR MORE INFORMATION ON
EXECUTIVE SOFTWARE PRODUCTS
Contact your favorite reseller, or contact us directly: Executive Software
International is located at 7590 N. Glenoaks Blvd., Burbank, CA 91504. U.S. and
Canada: 1-800-829-6468
Central and South America, Pacific Rim and Asia: 1-818-771-1600. Fax for both of
the above: 1-818-252-5514; e-mail for both of the above:
infodesk@executive.com
Web
for both of the above:
http://www.executive.com
Japan:
Sohei Electrical Instruments
Phone: 03-3447-7544
Fax: 03-3445-9156
e-mail:
info@sohei.co.jp
Web:
http://www.sohei.co.jp
Europe, Africa and the Middle East:
Executive Software Europe
Phone: (44) 1 342 327477
Fax: (44) 1 342 327390
e-mail:
hotline@execsoft.co.uk
Web:
http://www.execsoft.co.uk
If
you prefer to receive the text version, please click on
http://www.execsoft.com/eletter/eletter.asp.
FOR
BACK ISSUES
On
the World Wide Web, point your browser to:
http://www.diskeeper.com/eletter/previous/previous.asp
All
of our back issues are posted. You can read them online or download as many as
you like.
If
you don't have Web access or have trouble getting the issues you want, please
send an e-mail message, containing which issues you would like, to
editor@executive.com
ABOUT INSIGHT ON WINDOWS NT®/2000/XP
INSIGHT ON WINDOWS NT/2000/XP is electronically published monthly by Executive
Software International.
Editor: Lisa Engber
editor@executive.com
Please contact me with questions or comments about the eLetter.
Tips
Links Research: Lisa Engber
NOTE
ON TECHNICAL ACCURACY
Over
the last five years, more than 4,000,000 INSIGHT ON WINDOWS NT/2000/XP eLetter
issues have been distributed to some of the best technical people throughout the
world. The success of this eLetter is based in large part on the quality of
technical communication and recommendations we have sought to provide. Part of
maintaining that quality has been that if a recommendation required correction
we immediately did so. Should there ever be the need to do so now or in the
future, it will be corrected and provided in the next or subsequent editions.
The
user assumes the entire risk as to the accuracy and the use of this document.
REPRINT PERMISSION
For
reprint permission for any of the articles in the eLetter, please contact me at
editor@executive.com.
NOTICE:
We periodically send new product information electronically or survey those
individuals who voluntarily give us their e-mail address. We hope you enjoy
receiving this timely information. However, if you would like to remove yourself
from this list, please do not reply to this e-mail to be removed.
You have received this message from
esi-vp-marketing at the e-mail address: mattm@executive.com
To unsubscribe, send the above e-mail address in the
body of a message along with your name, on a separate line, to
unsubscribe@executive.com.
© 2004 Executive Software International, Inc. All
Rights Reserved. Executive Software, the Executive Software Logo, Diskeeper,
Sitekeeper, Smart Scheduling, "Set it and Forget" and Undelete are either
registered trademarks or trademarks owned by Executive Software International,
Inc. in the United States and/or other countries. Microsoft, Windows and Windows
NT are registered trademarks or trademarks of Microsoft Corporation in the
United States and other countries. All other trademarks are property of their
respective owners.
Executive Software 7590 N. Glenoaks Blvd.,
Burbank, CA 91504
|